Contents
Related
|
|
Building Services
Engineering (BSE) Design: Detailed Design
屋宇裝備工程設計: 詳細設計
|
The Design Process
At the concept design stage,
some initial concepts are explored and drawings or
models produced accordingly. These concepts are then
narrowed down to produce a scheme design, the general
arrangement of the favoured or proposed schemes. The
detailed design would reflect the chosen solution and
would include accurate plant and services distribution
sizing, and plant room layouts. The drawings/models
would be in double-line format at this stage. At the
end of this stage there would be sufficient
information produced to allow the project to be
successfully tendered and priced.
Detailed design is sometimes referred to as 'developed
design' or 'definition'. It is the process of taking
on and developing the approved concept design. By the
end of the detailed design process, the design should
be dimensionally correct and co-ordinated, describing
all the main components of the building and how they
fit together. However, technical aspects of the design
may require further development, design by specialists
may not yet have been fully incorporated into the
design and it will not have been packaged for tender.
Detailed design should provide sufficient information
for applications for statutory approval to be made.
Design Tasks
Based on the RIBA Plan
of Work, this design stage can be divided into two
phases and the main objectives of the design tasks are
shown below.
(a) Developed Design (Spatial Coordination)
- Develop the concept design
to include detailed information
- Confirm and finalise all
design requirements and solutions
- Prepare and apply for
detailed planning permission and statutory
approval
(b) Technical Design
- Prepare technical designs
and specifications (for tendering and
installation)
- Complete design
coordination and integration
- Finalise details on
calculations, drawings, zoning, interface and
schedules
BSE Team Working
To enable efficient teamwork,
each student group should clearly identify the
division of works and expected roles/contribution of
each team member. Usually one student will act as
the leader or coordinator for the project team. It
is recommended that the students should divide the
works into the following areas of building services
design but they do not have to cover all the areas.
- HVAC: Heating, ventilating
and air conditioning systems
- ELEC: Electrical power
supply and distribution
- FSS: Fire services systems
- P&D: Plumbing &
drainage systems
- LTG: Lighting system design
- GBD: Green building design
and sustainability
BSE Design Issues
When developing the detailed
design, students should consider the important
design requirements affecting the planning and
implementation of the building services systems. A
list of the typical design issues is given below as
general guidance only (and they are not exhaustive).
If needed, students may consider and propose their
main design concerns and they should discuss and
confirm with the design tutors before including
them.
- BIM project execution and
implementation
- Design coordination (with
other disciplines and among different building
services systems)
- Energy efficiency (building
energy design and performance modelling)
- Performance targets against
design criteria
- Installation, testing and
commissioning
- Measurement and
verification (of the building or system
performance)
- Operation and maintenance
- Preliminary cost estimate
and cost plan
Each student group should
examine the major design tasks and deliverables
appropriate for their building project with the aim
to develop sufficient design information for the
client and whole project team to proceed to the next
stage of the design process. Typical examples of the
design tasks and deliverables are shown as follows.
- Developed single line
diagrams and schematics showing connections to all
equipment (equipment, cables, pipes, ducts,
circuit breakers all sized)
- Developed drawings
(sections as necessary) indicating finalised plant
room locations, risers and service routes, initial
reflected ceiling plans.
- Utilities connections:
Finalise utility connections/installations and
liaise with local authorities
- Equipment: Confirm sizing
and generic selection, develop schedules
- Materials and equipment:
Prepare preliminary schedule(s) of major equipment
and sub-systems
- Distribution: Confirm sizes
for services distribution and containment networks
(ducts, cables, pipes, cable trays) including
allowance for access and maintenance.
- Interface requirements:
With existing buildings and equipment, and with
other disciplines.
- Zones: Finalise zoning
plans for all services
Resources:
Design
guides:
- Building
Services Design:
- Coordination:
- BIM
Checklists – Modeling &
Coordination https://www.united-bim.com/resources/bim-checklists/
- From
confusion to collaboration: My journey
through the evolution of BIM
coordination https://bimtrack.co/blog/blog-posts/from-confusion-to-collaboration-my-journey-through-the-evolution-of-bim-coordination
- MEP
Coordination - Designing Buildings
Wiki https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/MEP_Coordination
- MEP
Coordination (with BIM) http://ibse.hk/SBS5411/SBS5411_1819_08.pdf
- Michie, A. and Ogle, J.,
1982. Co-ordination
of Building Services: Design
Stage Methods, Technical
Note TN 1/82, Building Services
Research and Information
Association, Bracknell, Bershire.
- Mitchell, S., 2003. Services
Co-ordination with
Structural Beams: Guidance
for a Defect-free Interface,
Building Services Research and
Information Association,
Bracknell, Berkshire, England.
- Sands, J., 2002. Fire Extinguishing Systems: A Guide
to Their Integration
with Other Building Services, Building
Services Research and
Information
Association,
Bracknell, Berkshire,
England.
- The
typical stages of MEP coordination https://www.thecadroom.com/the-typical-stages-of-mep-coordination/
- Design
Documentation Guidelines (New Zealand
Construction Industry Council)
(2008) [PDF]
- Preamble
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Architecture
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Electrical Services
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Electrical Ancillary
Services
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Fire Engineering
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Fire Protection
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: HVAC Services
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Hydraulic Services
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Structural
- Design
Documentation Guidelines: Co-ordination Checklists
- Design
Guidelines (New Zealand Construction Industry
Council) (2022)
http://nzcic.co.nz/resources/guidelines/
- Design
skills (general):
- Sustainable
Building Design:
Useful
references:
- Churcher
D., Ronceray M. & Sands J., 2018. Design
Framework for Building Services, 5th ed., BG 6/2018, Building
Services Research and Information Association,
Bracknell, Berkshire, England.
- Hall F. &
Greeno R., 2017. Building
Services Handbook, 9th ed., Routledge, Oxon
& New York. [HKALL]
- Hall F.
& Greeno R., 2013. Building
Services Handbook, 7th ed.,
Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, U.K. [HKALL][690 H17][6th ed.: ebook via ebrary]
- Hawkins G. (ed.), 2011. Rules of Thumb: Guidelines for
Building Services, 5th ed., Building Services Research and
Information Association, Bracknell, Berkshire,
England. [HKALL][697 R935]
- Pennycook
K., 2007. Design
Checks for HVAC: A Quality Control Framework,
BSRIA Guide BG 4/2007, 2nd ed., Building Services
Research and Information Association, Bracknell,
Berkshire, England. [HKALL][697 R1][AV 697 P416]
- Pennycook
K. 2006. Design
Checks for Electrical Services, Application
Guide BG 3/2006, Building Services Research and
Information Association, Bracknell, Berkshire,
England. [HKALL][628.0941 P41][AV 621.31924 P41 d]
- Pennycook
K. 2006. Design
Checks for Public Health Engineering,
Application Guide BG 2/2006, Building Services
Research and Information Association, Bracknell,
Berkshire, England. [HKALL][621.31924 P4][AV 621.31924 P4 d]
- Tudor R.,
2017. Building Services Reports, BG
71/2017, Building Services
Research and Information Association, Bracknell,
Berkshire, England. [CIS
E-database]
- Developed
design reports [PDF]
|